How to get repeat customers

Jul 29, 2025

People moving stars

Why Repeat Customers Matter

For resellers, getting a customer to buy from you once is great—but earning their repeat business is where real growth happens. Repeat customers are more likely to spend more, trust your brand, and recommend you to others. The good news? Building loyal buyers doesn’t require fancy tricks or a huge team. With a few simple systems and habits, you can create a reliable foundation for ongoing sales.

1. Keep Listings and Inventory in Sync Across All Platforms

Customers expect a smooth buying experience, and nothing derails trust faster than canceled orders due to out-of-stock items. If you sell on multiple sites—such as eBay, Etsy, Shopify, or local marketplaces—it’s easy for inventory to become inconsistent.

  • Centralize your inventory: Use a single system to track what you have and where it’s listed. This keeps you from accidentally overselling.

  • Sync listings automatically: Tools like Gavelbase let you update your inventory and have those changes reflected across all your sales channels in real time. There are other options too, including SellEdge, but choose one that fits your scale and budget.

  • Regularly audit listings: Once a week, check for mismatches or errors. This habit can prevent headaches and keep your customers happy.

2. Assign Basic Team Roles (Even If You’re Solo)

If you work with family, friends, or even just yourself, defining roles—even loosely—helps avoid confusion and mistakes. Clear responsibilities ensure orders move smoothly and customers get what they expect.

  • Order Processing: Who checks for new sales and gets orders packed?

  • Customer Communication: Who responds to questions or handles issues?

  • Listing Management: Who adds or updates new products?

  • Shipping/Pickup Coordination: Who prints labels or arranges pickup schedules?

Even as a solo seller, blocking out time for each task helps you stay organized and deliver reliable service.

3. Track Sales and Fees—Know What’s Working

Understanding what sells (and what costs you money) is key to building a sustainable business. Tracking sales and fees helps you spot trends, set better prices, and identify your best (and worst) products.

  • Log every sale: Use a spreadsheet, a notebook, or a tool like Gavelbase to record sales, fees, and your net profit. The more you know, the smarter your decisions will be.

  • Review monthly: Take an hour at the end of each month to see which items brought repeat buyers. Focus your efforts there.

4. Make Shipping or Pickup Seamless

Shipping hiccups or confusing pickup instructions can turn a happy customer into a one-time buyer. Streamlining this step is a quick win for repeat business.

  • Clear communication: Send tracking numbers and pickup details promptly. Use templates to save time.

  • Easy returns: A simple, fair return policy makes customers feel safe buying from you again.

  • Professional packaging: Even basic packaging should protect the item and look presentable. Consider including a thank-you note for a personal touch.

5. Stay in Touch—But Don’t Spam

After a sale, nurture the relationship gently:

  • Send a follow-up: A short message asking if they’re happy with their purchase can encourage feedback and show you care.

  • Offer a small discount: For their next purchase, a code or free shipping can invite repeat business.

  • Consider a simple newsletter: If you have permission, send occasional updates about new arrivals or special offers. Keep it infrequent and relevant.

6. Make the Customer Feel Valued

Small gestures go a long way. Personalized thank-you notes, remembering a repeat buyer’s preferences, or even a quick email to let them know about something they might like can set you apart from bigger, faceless sellers.

Final Thoughts

Getting repeat customers comes down to reliability, clear communication, and showing that you care. Start small: pick one area above to improve each week. Over time, these habits will compound—turning first-time buyers into loyal fans, helping your reselling business grow steadily and sustainably.